Red Flags in Financial Statements-Every Investor Must Know!

---

💣 The Truth Behind the Numbers: Are You Reading the Signs?

Why the red flags in financial statements get overlooked often?

It was 2008. The stock market was booming, and Satyam Computer Services was the pride of India’s corporate world.
The company had just bagged the Golden Peacock Award for Excellence in Corporate Governance — a badge of honor few could dream of.
Analysts called it a “blue-chip gem,” and investors rushed to buy more shares, confident in its spotless reputation.

But within months, the mask fell.
The same company that won awards for transparency was exposed in one of India’s biggest accounting frauds — ₹7,000 crore of fake profits, inflated cash balances, and falsified invoices.

Around the world, stories like Wirecard, Enron, and IL&FS followed the same pattern — glittering success hiding deep cracks.
Every fraud left behind the same painful question:

Were the red flags always there — and did we just fail to see them?

This blog dives into those warning signs — the subtle yet powerful red flags in financial statements that can reveal when a company’s story doesn’t match its numbers.
Because in investing, it’s not optimism that saves your money — it’s awareness.

---

🧭 10-Point Cash Flow Red-Flag Checklist for Investors

#	Check This	Why It Matters / Red Flag Signal	Real-World Example
1	Is Cash Flow from Operations (CFO) consistently positive?	Profitable businesses should generate cash. Multiple years of negative CFO = unsustainable.	Kingfisher Airlines – persistent negative CFO led to debt trap.
2	Compare CFO vs Net Profit	CFO should roughly track profit. If profit > CFO for 2–3 years → likely aggressive revenue recognition.	Satyam, Enron.
3	Check CFO/Net Profit Ratio (>1 ideally)	A healthy company converts most of its earnings into cash. <1 indicates weak cash collection or fake sales.	Satyam – ratio <0.5 before scandal.
4	Look at Free Cash Flow (FCF = CFO – Capex)	Negative FCF over long periods → dependency on external funding.	Kingfisher, Start-ups like WeWork pre-IPO.
5	Watch “Other Current Assets/Liabilities” in CFO adjustments	Large swings here can be used to manipulate CFO.	Enron used complex structures to inflate CFO.
6	Scrutinize Investing Cash Flows (CFI)	Sale of assets or “investments in subsidiaries” might hide poor operations or round-tripping.	Wirecard – fake “escrow” accounts & investments.
7	Analyze Financing Cash Flow (CFF)	Rising borrowings or frequent equity dilution despite profit = cash crunch.	Yes Bank – relied on fresh borrowings.
8	Verify Cash Balances with Debt Levels	High cash + high debt = questionable. Why borrow if cash exists?	Wirecard claimed high cash but was actually missing €1.9 bn.
9	Look for One-time or Unusual Inflows	Sudden inflows from asset sales, grants, or subsidiaries may inflate CFO temporarily.	Satyam & Enron both showed “one-off” boosts.
10	Read Auditor’s and Notes to Accounts for cash-flow anomalies	Auditors often flag inconsistencies in “bank balances,” “related-party cash flows,” or “non-reconciled statements.”	Wirecard, Yes Bank (RBI observations).

⚙️ How to Apply This Practically

1. Pull last 5 years’ cash flow data (from Annual Report or Screener.in).
2. Create simple ratios:
   • CFO / Net Profit
   • FCF = CFO – Capex
   • Debt / CFO
3. Watch for trends, not one-year anomalies.
4. Cross-verify cash with borrowings — if both rise together, investigate.
5. Always read the Notes section — that’s where hidden details lie.

---

✅ Quick Rule of Thumb

“If profits rise but cash doesn’t, believe the cash.”

Because cash is reality, profit is opinion.

---

🚨 Red Flags in Profit & Loss Statement (with Real-World Examples)

---

1️⃣ Rapid Revenue Growth without Cash Support

Red Flag: Revenue growing fast but not matched by cash inflow or customer receipts.
Why It’s Risky: Indicates fake/inflated sales, round-tripping, or channel stuffing.
Case: Satyam Computer (India, 2009)

• Reported strong double-digit revenue growth every year.
• But receivables kept rising, and cash didn’t increase proportionately.
• Later revealed that invoices were fabricated to show fake revenue.
  → Check: Revenue growth vs. CFO growth; Debtors turnover ratio.

---

2️⃣ Consistently Rising Profits with Flat or Declining Sales

Red Flag: Margins rising unnaturally while sales stagnate.
Why It’s Risky: Artificial margin inflation via reduced depreciation, deferred expenses, or lower provisions.
Case: Enron (USA, 2001)

• Reported massive profit growth by using mark-to-market accounting — recognizing future gains as present income.
• Actual sales and cash lagged behind.
  → Check: Profit growth vs. sales growth; sudden margin expansion.

Mark-to-market accounting is legal, but it becomes dangerous when abused. Enron, for example, booked projected profits as actual income long before cash arrived, using unrealistic assumptions. For investors, this is a clear red flag—profits on paper don’t always mean real money in the bank.

---

3️⃣ High “Other Income” Contribution

Red Flag: A big chunk of profit coming from “Other Income” rather than core operations.
Why It’s Risky: Non-operating income (interest, asset sale, forex gain) may be one-time or non-recurring.
Case: Yes Bank (India, 2017–19)

• Showed stable profit numbers despite rising NPAs.
• Part of the earnings came from “bond trading gains” and write-back of provisions.
  → Check: % of Other Income in total profit; sustainability of that income.

---

4️⃣ Frequent Changes in Accounting Policies or Estimates

Red Flag: Change in depreciation method, inventory valuation, or revenue recognition timing.
Why It’s Risky: Such changes can boost or delay expenses to inflate profit.
Case: Jet Airways (India)

• Changed depreciation policy to extend asset life → reduced annual depreciation expense.
• Helped temporarily improve profits before eventual collapse.
  → Check: Notes to Accounts — “Change in accounting policies.”

---

5️⃣ Low or Declining Expense Ratios without Operational Explanation

Red Flag: Sharp drop in cost of goods sold or operating expenses without clear reason.
Why It’s Risky: Indicates expense under-reporting, capitalization, or deferred recognition.
Case: DHFL (India)

• Expenses understated by showing interest costs as “capitalized” assets, boosting short-term profits.
  → Check: Expense-to-sales ratios; sudden improvement in margins.

---

6️⃣ High Reported Profit but Low EPS Growth

Red Flag: EPS growth lagging behind profit growth.
Why It’s Risky: Means frequent equity dilution or aggressive accounting adjustments.
Case: Suzlon Energy (India)

• Reported profits while issuing more shares and booking notional gains.
• EPS stagnated despite high reported PAT.
  → Check: Compare PAT growth vs EPS growth; dilution impact.

---

7️⃣ Sudden Jump in “Other Expenses” or Unexplained Items

Red Flag: Vague line items like “miscellaneous expenses,” “exceptional items,” or “adjustments.”
Why It’s Risky: Hides write-offs, penalties, or related-party payments.
Case: IL&FS (India, 2018)

• Large “miscellaneous expenses” masked provisioning for bad loans and project losses.
  → Check: Trend of “Other Expenses” and read notes carefully.

---

8️⃣ Low Tax Outgo despite High Reported Profits

Red Flag: High book profits but very low actual tax payment or deferred tax adjustments.
Why It’s Risky: Indicates manipulation, deferred taxes, or use of tax shelters.
Case: Enron again — paid negligible taxes on billions of “profits.”
→ Check: Effective Tax Rate = Tax / PBT → should not be drastically low for long.

---

9️⃣ Frequent “Exceptional Gains” Saving Results

Red Flag: Company shows profit mainly because of “one-time” gains every year.
Why It’s Risky: Genuine business performance is weak; management masking issues.
Case: Reliance Capital / ADAG firms (2015–18)

• Several “exceptional gains” from asset sales and revaluation helped maintain profit.
  → Check: Recurrence of “one-time” gains; remove them for normalized profit.

---

🔟 Promoter Compensation Rising Despite Weak Performance

Red Flag: Salaries, commissions, or bonuses to promoters increasing even when profits or revenues fall.
Why It’s Risky: Signals governance issues and poor alignment with shareholders.
Case: Kingfisher Airlines / Vijay Mallya

• Management took high compensation despite continuous losses.
  → Check: Director remuneration trend vs company performance.

---

⚙️ Quick Investor Ratios to Detect P&L Red Flags

Metric	Formula / Check	Healthy Range
CFO / Net Profit	Cash conversion of profit	> 1 preferred
Operating Margin Consistency	EBIT / Sales	Should be stable; not volatile without reason
Other Income %	Other Income / Total Income	< 10–15% ideal
Effective Tax Rate	Tax / PBT	Should be near statutory rate (25–30% in India)
Debt Service Coverage	EBIT / (Interest + Principal)	> 1.5 preferred

📘 Key Lesson

“When the story in the P&L looks too good to be true — check the cash flow and the notes.”

---

🚨 Balance Sheet Red Flags (with Real-World Case Studies)

1️⃣ Inflated or Fake Assets

Red Flag: Sudden rise in assets (cash, investments, receivables) without supporting business activity.
Why It’s Risky: Common trick to show inflated financial strength or hide missing money.
Case: Wirecard (Germany, 2020)

• Claimed €1.9 billion in “cash balances” held in escrow accounts that didn’t exist.
• Auditors (EY) couldn’t verify bank confirmations.
  → Check: Cash balances vs CFO; auditor notes on verification of balances.

---

2️⃣ Rising Receivables vs Sales

Red Flag: Receivables growing faster than revenue.
Why It’s Risky: Indicates fake sales, delayed collections, or weak customer base.
Case: Satyam Computer (India, 2009)

• Trade receivables rose sharply compared to revenue growth.
• Revealed later that many invoices were fictitious.
  → Check: Debtors Turnover = Sales / Receivables → should remain stable.

---

3️⃣ High or Growing Inventory without Sales Growth

Red Flag: Inventory piling up even as sales stagnate.
Why It’s Risky: Could indicate overproduction, obsolete stock, or fake capitalization.
Case: Ricoh India (2016)

• Reported huge jump in inventory and receivables to inflate revenue.
• Later disclosed major accounting irregularities.
  → Check: Inventory Turnover; Inventory growth vs Sales growth.

---

4️⃣ Capitalizing Operating Expenses

Red Flag: Unusually high “Capital Work-in-Progress (CWIP)” or “Intangible Assets.”
Why It’s Risky: Expenses booked as assets → inflates profits and total assets.
Case: Infrastructure Leasing & Financial Services (IL&FS, India, 2018)

• Capitalized project costs that should’ve been expensed, masking true losses.
  → Check: CWIP and intangible growth vs actual new projects.

---

5️⃣ High Related-Party Loans or Investments

Red Flag: Loans/advances to subsidiaries, associates, or promoters without clear recovery terms.
Why It’s Risky: Cash diversion or round-tripping.
Case: DHFL (India, 2019)

• Large inter-company loans routed to promoter-linked entities, later found to be siphoning.
  → Check: Related Party Disclosures in Notes; compare loans vs group revenue.

---

6️⃣ Sharp Increase in Goodwill or Intangibles

Red Flag: Rising goodwill from frequent acquisitions.
Why It’s Risky: Used to mask overpayment or inflate total asset base.
Case: Jet Airways / Fortis Healthcare

• Acquisitions led to inflated goodwill, later written off.
  → Check: Goodwill as % of Total Assets; watch for future impairment losses.

---

7️⃣ Hidden Debt through Off-Balance-Sheet Liabilities

Red Flag: Leases, guarantees, or SPVs not reflected as liabilities.
Why It’s Risky: Hides true leverage and risk.
Case: Enron (USA, 2001)

• Used hundreds of off-balance-sheet partnerships (SPEs) to hide debt.
  → Check: Notes on Contingent Liabilities and Commitments.

---

8️⃣ Negative Working Capital in Non-FMCG Businesses

Red Flag: Current liabilities > current assets in industries not typically prepaid by customers.
Why It’s Risky: Indicates cash flow stress, delayed supplier payments.
Case: Yes Bank (2018–20)

• Negative working capital arose as deposits fled and loans turned bad.
  → Check: Current Ratio = Current Assets / Current Liabilities → should be >1.

---

9️⃣ Frequent Equity Dilution Despite Profits

Red Flag: New share issues or warrants even when retained earnings are strong.
Why It’s Risky: Indicates poor cash generation; promoter enrichment at minority expense.
Case: Suzlon Energy (India)

• Repeated equity issuances to fund losses and pay debt.
  → Check: Change in share capital vs retained earnings trend.

---

🔟 Auditor or Credit Rating Resignations

Red Flag: Sudden resignation or qualification in auditor’s report.
Why It’s Risky: Often happens just before major fraud revelations.
Case:

• CG Power (India, 2019) – auditor flagged fund diversion.
• Manpasand Beverages (India, 2018) – auditor resigned before fraud exposed.
  → Check: Auditor notes, qualifications, emphasis of matter, and resignation reasons.

---

📊 Summary Table: Balance Sheet Red Flags

Red Flag	Likely Manipulation	Example
Fake/Inflated Cash	Round-tripping or missing money	Wirecard
Receivables > Sales Growth	Fake revenue	Satyam
High CWIP/Intangibles	Expense capitalization	IL&FS
High Related-Party Loans	Fund diversion	DHFL
Hidden Debt (Off-BS)	Leverage concealment	Enron
Sudden Goodwill Jump	Overvaluation of M&A	Jet Airways
Negative Working Capital	Liquidity stress	Yes Bank
Auditor Changes	Fraud cover-up	Manpasand, CG Power

🧭 Practical Investor Checks

1. Compare asset growth vs revenue growth. Assets growing faster = efficiency drop or asset inflation.
2. Read Notes to Accounts every time. Most manipulations hide in footnotes.
3. Check debt trends vs CFO. If debt rises but CFO doesn’t, beware.
4. Track auditor comments & resignations.
5. Cross-verify cash with interest income. Big cash → should yield interest; if not, fake.

---

ESG Red Flags in Financial Statements & Reporting

From an ESG lens, red flags go beyond just profits—they reveal how responsibly a company operates. Warning signs include:

• Environmental: Lack of disclosure on carbon emissions, excessive resource consumption, or sudden rise in “green” claims without credible data (greenwashing).
• Social: Frequent labor disputes, poor worker safety records, or unusually high employee turnover that contradicts “people-first” claims.
• Governance: Related-party transactions, auditor resignations, opaque ownership structures, or delays in ESG/sustainability reporting.

Why it matters: Weak ESG practices often correlate with financial manipulation, compliance risks, or reputational damage. Inconsistent or overly polished ESG reports—without independent verification—are major red flags that a company may be using ESG as a PR tool rather than a genuine framework.

---

✅ Final Takeaway

“Balance Sheets tell you what’s real — P&L tells you what they wish were real.”
Always reconcile P&L + CFO + Balance Sheet together for true financial health.

---

⚠️ Call to Action for Investors: Don’t Just Read Profits — Read Between the Lines

💡 Most corporate disasters don’t happen overnight — they unfold slowly in the financial statements.
The signs are always there — in cash flow mismatches, bloated receivables, or auditor notes that nobody bothers to read.

👉 As an investor, your best protection isn’t luck — it’s literacy.
Learn to read beyond the headlines and glossy earnings presentations.
Every rupee you invest is a vote of trust. Don’t give that trust blindly.

✅ Before you invest, ask yourself:

1. Do profits convert into real cash?
2. Are assets genuine, or just accounting entries?
3. Is debt rising faster than business growth?
4. Are auditors, credit raters, and management aligned — or exiting quietly?

🚨 If the numbers don’t tell a consistent story — walk away.
Greed makes you chase high returns; wisdom makes you protect your capital.

---

“Markets reward curiosity, not complacency.”
Read. Question. Compare. Verify.
Because the next Satyam, Wirecard, or IL&FS will again look like a success story — until it isn’t.

Read blogs on corporate governance here.

Weaver – Critical Red Flags in Financial Statement Reviews
This resource outlines key indicators such as unusual fluctuations in account balances and inconsistent trends across reporting periods, emphasizing the significance of early identification to mitigate risks. weaver.com